If there was a war between Palestine and Israel
and Palestine won
do you think Palestinians would take Jewish women as slaves/servants?
Warad Hebron
(she doesn't know what she means by the term "sabaya")
What do you mean by that?
I said, weren't there sabaya in wars?
She said I don't understand what the word sabaya means
This is something from the very old times
they don't do it anymore
Long ago when there used to be wars
when the war was won women would be taken as slaves
before I said slaves, they said "do you mean as hostages?"
detained. I said no, as slaves
and now they are discussing
No, I don't think this would happen
because these aren't our morals
We all remember what happened in the war in Gaza
and Shalit who was kidnapped the soldier
and he was not treated as a slave
He was treated in a very very good way
Because our humanity does not allow us to treat people that way
Amjad Hebron
No, it's not acceptable
I think "sabaya" is an old
it is not acceptable now
and our Islam
If we win, we will treat them (Israelis) as Islamic
behaviour
No killing, no "sabaya" nothing else
Just (send them) out of our land
It is not acceptable now
in Islam, because
our time now
is different than it was in the the past
say 1400 years ago
I don't think it is acceptable now
in Islam
If there was a war between Israelis and Palestinians
could Palestinians take Israeli "sabaya"?
No, of course not
Naaman Ramallah
I have no knowledge of this
I heard that there might be (sabaya) but I am not sure exactly how
I don't have knowledge about this
where there should be sabaya and where there shouldn't be sabaya
I don't have the conviction and I don't have the religious knowledge
to know what is proper and not proper
I won't go into something with such a grey area or not very clear
To me, I have my doubts that this might be allowed or forbidden
The Prophet, peace be upon Him
said "what is allowed is clear"
"and what is not allowed is clear"
"and those who are in doubt or go into things that are doubtful"
"have committed sins"
If there was a war with Israel and the Palestinians won
Ashraf Hebron
Could Palestinians take Jewish women as slaves?
No, of course not
It is forbidden
It is just wrong
If there was a war with Israel and Palestine won
do you think Palestinians can take Jewish women as slaves?
Mostafa Ramallah
No
Do you think anyone will say yes?
Of course
That was disappointing, sorry
Why do you think some people will say yes
Because Israeli women are beautiful
Ahmad Jaaba
If there is a war with Israelis
and Palestinians win
can Palestinians take Israeli women as slaves?
Yes - Why?
Because that is how we Arabs are
that is our nature
Is he saying it seriously or making a joke?
I am serious
Where would they go? They would have no place to go
The women? - Yes
So they are better off with you?
Yes, of course, because we have very merciful hearts
and "we would put them in our eyes"
Do you really believe what you said about sabaya?
Yes
Really?
Ok, seriously, seriously
we wouldn't do this
Our religion wouldn't allow this
as we say "if we are ok with this for our family"
"we have to be ok with this for other people's family"
since I am not ok for this to happen with my family members
I wouldn't want it to happen to someone else
Aisha Ramallah
the Prophet Mohammad
I obey

Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét