Face to dangers and risks, we don't react the same way.
More we're alone, more we feel responsable.
Explications by Anthony Jolly, Valerie Lucas and Frederic Furdemont.
What would I have done in such circumstances ?
Would I have been spectator or actor ?
We already asked these questions to ourselves, in front of a dangerous situation,
like, for example, a fight in subway.
Understand why some people take part to the fight when others keep looking away.
That's the mission that Jonathan Lambinet gave it to him.
Hey but it's us !
Indeed, sometimes ago France 2 established contact with us to make an apparition in their TV journal.
But they wanted us to do something we had already done
so we thought it was maybe the perfect occasion, for us, with this shooting,
to show you the backstage of WYR.
Now you're going to see our social experience that we realized, its new.
And of course, at the end of the video, you're gonna see the complete subject of the TV journal.
That is gonna be interesting for you, it's to see that compared to the same shoot,
the things we kept, everyone from our side, can be two things totally different.
Excuse me, are you from here ?
Not at all!
Actually, I'm looking for an hotel or something like that.
I really can't help you, I'm sorry.
I look at you, I follow you for a certain time....
If you want I go with you !
Do you know where Ibis hotel is ? - Yeah, it's not far away.
Would you like to go with me ? Or you can tell me where it is.
Uh, no, you come with.
No, she wants to go alone so let her do.
She's gonna ask to someone else. You see that she's not feeling comfortable sir!
What do you want me to do ? - It's not about this, it's about respect...
Given that what's happens sometines, we can't know !
Aren't you comfortable with me ? - Actually no.
She doesn't even know you !
You pulled her by her arm, saying "come" ! - Yes, exactly!
It's sad to be mean like that, sir.
But I'm not mean, on the contrary, I want to be really nice with her!
Justly, that's scaring me !
More than that, Ibis hotel isn't here. We don't care, we're gonna ask to someone at the station.
Don't approach, I put my fist in your face if you keep going !
Hey, get away! Get away!
Oh, is that a joke ? - We are actors.
- Would You React ? Oh yeah, I already watched.
- Hey miss, you know you're good ?
- Are you crazy or what ?
Did you see your make up ? How do you talk to me ? Hey are you a whore or what ?
[The two girls walk in direction of policemen]
Do you know each other ? - No.
No ? Don't you have something to do of your day you ? Yes, why ?
So why are you boring miss ?
He was on the verge of being kicked !
He's an actor.
Explain to us just a moment how it happened, how you lived the situation?
It happens to us too when we're alone in town. - Is it a reccurent situation in town ?
I think if I had been alone, I would haven't took part.
When we're two it gives more trust.
I don't want to be punched, it's a little selfish...
I didn't want to be an extern element that will make the thing worst.
When we're going to Anspach boulevard, the number of times that we are being whistled when we wear a skirt...
It became regular. We are looked, whistled and .. we don't say anything!
[There are a social experiment AND a TV news report backstages]
We took time to react ..
We don't know each other, I don't know who you are !
No it's dead, you don't follow me everywhere like that !
Oh come on ! - Hey are you sick or what ?
You don't touch me ! Come oon !
I don't know, I don't know him !
What are you doing ? Why are you touching this girl ?
It's an hidden camera ! You're kidding!
It's normal no ? It's our job!
Did you do the same in the tramway ? - Yeah.
Really good actors ! - Thanks.
Thank you because, given the debriefing, he's gonna break us, it's good to...
I don't know anybody who refuse me!
Step back ! She just told us that she didn't want you came closer from her.
What are your words for her ?
Is she your daughter, your sister ? No, it's just a girl.
Did you see how she's arranged .. Me it makes me feel like... - What how she's arranged ?
But did you see yourself ? You look like nothing, it's about how YOU're arranged dude!
In some cases, there is rape, fight... and we have to react before that.
And are you not scared to be a part of this story and the guy gets mad ?
We are three.
[Fr2 journalist] What are the reason that push you to make videos ?
- The fact that making videos, to show some people who react,
I'm sure its boost some things for persons,
its push them to think:
"Me too, I can be this girl who react!"
[Fr2] He speaks a lot with his hands, we're gonna cut this plan!
[Last try]
We don't know each other! No!
Did you see something strange?
I saw her being annoyed.
What was your reaction about it ?
I didn't react at all.
It's not a problem, but I'd like to know why ?
- I didn't want any problem.
He could attack me too.
Be honest, we try to get things.
Me, I didn't react because I saw the guy was also flexible lets say..
Journalist : but you were living right ?
Actually no, I was just going to the station, but given that I saw the guy was obeying to miss,
I thought "I look at anyway", I was still in observation.
Journalist : she didnt seem in a good posture anyway..
Yeah, but given that the guy wasn't acting yet, so ..
Looking at is that an action or not ? Oh for me, yes, notwithstanding.
Okay, it's interesting.
From the point of view of a gril who's being attacked,
do you think they have the same vision of things ?
Not at all. - It's interesting.
Your answers make us thinking of : who are we in the society ?
So, just for that my friend, I'd like to congrats you.
[ And this is the sequence by Fr2 ]
Surrounded of amateurs videographers and two volunteer comedians,
Jonathan Lambinet is going to try, for us, a new social experiment :
Fake the harassment of a young girl in the street.
We're going to analyze how people, of a general way, react
to, then, bring little solutions because we are certain that people want to react well.
The male actor approach the female comedian with words very raw...
- You know you're good you ?
to provoke people's attention.
It's good, I don't know you. - What you don't know me ?
You don't touch me, it's dead! - Girs like you, I do all week long.
First witnesses are chocked, look at the scene like these two men...
Hey, did you see how you're dressed up ? - So what ?
... then walk away without taking part.
You're just a girl uh - Ah I'm just a girl, yeah..
Situation extends. The actor becomes physically threathening.
This man looks away.
Two other persons observe. Still no reaction.
That's the experts call the "spectator effect".
If there are a lot of witnesses of a situation where the emergency is required,
the probability to take part is gonna be weaker because we are, finally, disempowered.
We have the impression that other persons could take part, that's the spectator effect,
and in that case, we are more inactive, more inhibited.
We retry the experiment later.
Two men walk through like if nothing was happening, despite the furtive acts of the actor.
We ask about his passivity to this witness.
I prefer observe before taking part directly.
Because if the guy has, for example, a knife of something and that we want..
I know stories like that where people wanted to separate and, at the end,
Are the people who take instead the people in front of.
Me, I was in the observation before you know.
People have the impression that when they watch, they help mais not at all!
An extra look is an extra weight for the victim!
I think he led an essential information to try to understand the inactivity of people.
During the three hours of shooting, a lot of people chose to take part.
It's the case of these two women.
Step back, she just told you she didn't want you came closer from her.
What are your words for her right now ?
Is she your sister, your daughter ?
No, it's just a girl. I just feel touched because it's what a girl supports.
Congrats, well played! They are actors.
Actually, his words were really chocking, wow..
It was the ultime cliché of the guy who is rejected and says : nobody rejects me!
And it's in these certain cases there are rapes, fights.. And we have to react before it.
The two women knew be brave, particullary
because they identifiated themselves to the victim.
It's one of others reasons of altruism : the way to help people who look like us.
It's the end of this journal, thanks for followed us. In a moment...
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét