Why do Jewish settlers beat
Dvir Ariel
and destroy the Palestinian's things?
Not for all of them
What? - Not for all Palestinians
No way, of course not
Only those that deserve it... kidding
No, we are against all those kind of things
But it happens, correct?
Just like it happens on the other side
You mean Palestinians who destroy things that belong to Jews
We don't justify either
but on both sides, there are always extremists
that do harm
So what can be done about that?
Explaining, education
Again
if you take a particular community
you will always have the extremists
the radicals that create the problems
What do you do?
It's mostly about education, explanation
That's it
Becky Shomron
Look around at all of my neighbours here
I have been living here 17 years
never in my life have I heard of someone attacking somebody else
That is propaganda
That does not happen here
These are civilized people
we are doctors, lawyers, teachers, social workers
That is not in our agenda, at all
The Rabbi of this Yeshiva was murdered by the Arabs
On the other hand
But I will stick to the question
But there have been, for example in the Nablus area, olive groves were burned
in Duma, there was a family that was killed
What are your thoughts on that?
How many Jews were murdered during...
I asked Palestinians that
I am asking you guys as Jews what do you think
First of all, they haven't found any evidence who actually committed the crimes
We are talking about Duma
I think there is a lot of misinformation and propaganda out there
People buring the trees We don't know who is doing the actions
People believe... Let's rephrase it
You are uncomfortable with the fact that this sounds very one-sided
This is a very one-sided question
Absolutely
That's how a lot of people in the world see Jewish settlers
They see you as stealing Palestinian land
and attacking Palestinians on a day to day basis
That's how Palestinians..
That's what they tell me down there (refering to nearby Palestinian village)
That's what they believe
Speak to that
I think it is misinformation
People want to live their lives People want to live peacefully
People want to live their day to day lives
go to work, come home from their work come home to their families
We are not out looking for violence
People may react occasionally
to a situation that is beyond their control
but I do not think anybody is out there for any reason
wanting to fight and cause harm to anybody else
and we look at the people who cause harm as the minority
most people are nice
are kind thoughtful human beings
that just want to live and exist
Why do settlers attack Palestinians?
Yakir Itamar
Speak on behalf of... - the entire nation?
Kidding
I don't know
First, do you think it is true?
Do I think that settlers attack Palestinians?
I think there are settlers who attack Palestinians
Why?
For the same reason that Palestinians attack Israelis
Because they think
the other shouldn't be here
You understand?
Do you want to say something from the side?
Go ahead
I think that is some settler
decides to attack a Palestinian
or do something (bad) to him
He will look for one
The same if...
(those that attack) are criminals it is not because they are settlers
Of course
He doesn't need to be a settler
it could be someone who lives in Rehovot
But from the askers perception
in the media, that is what they say
She said that these are criminals
and not connected to being settlers
First of all, they are criminals because they are breaking the law
That it's settlers, then it's settlers
it depends if a settler did it or not
It is like saying Tel Aviv people rape girls
- anyone want something to eat...
I have no response to that
as a person who lives in Tel Aviv
Vered Har Bracha
If I am 40 years old
most of my life
You grew up on Har Grizim
I grew up in Holland, converted then moved to Israel
then to Jerusalem
in that 20 years
before
Until I was 18, no, until I was 12
and then from Jerusalem to this area
This was in Har Grizim
Most of it, yes
Who is thinking we are?
Who said we are?
a bunch of people named at the beginning of this video
it is a very common perception outside of Israel
It is very...
sexy thing that Jewish people are attacking Arabs here
The truth is I never did it
My kids, my family, never
There are people who have done it
Few
In the US you have people who steal
so are all the Americans thieves? No
Same answer
Batsheva Nofim
They respond
They respond I will tell you why
That was very short I will explain myself
You can take a time segment
and respond only to that
You see the Jew attacking the Palestinian "oh, what's he doing?"
What you don't see are all the things that never hit the headlines
Give an example
I can tell you about numerous times
that Palestinians came up to the hills where we lived
stole cattle, tried breaking into houses
did even worse things
and a lot of those things never hit the news
I can tell you about driving
through Arab villages where just for being Jewish
we were attacked
I personally, sitting in a car with five babies
my babies
we were attacked by Palestinians
and I don't think I look harmful
I don't carry a weapon
neither do my babies
and we were attacked
simply because we are Jewish
I am not justifying attacks
on either side
But I can understand it
So you know from your time living in Itamar
that Jews did take revenge
Yes but I don't...
I don't know from the media what is true and what is not
Absolutely
I can tell you I know of one case
but that case was not of the people of Itamar
It was of a different settlement
What happened there was
a woman drove through an Arab city
she was attacked
she was basically thrown out of her car
and left on her own
in the Arab village
and the fact that she wasn't murdered is
just a miracle, really
So her neighbours
came to the town and
they made a bit of chaos
What do you mean? - I don't know exactly
I think they simply came with their cars made noise
blocked the road for a few hours
They didn't do anything significant
It was more a matter of passing on a message
of "you can't bully us"
"you can't dictate our lives"
a woman should be able to drive home without fearing for her life
Akiva Yizhar
I think
whoever asked that question only saw one part of the video
meaning, look at the broad picture
Who is attacking who?
You tell me
Over the past... since 1982
Thousands of Jews were killed... ok, hundreds were killed, thousands injured
So you look at the specific picture that CNN decides to show you
of a
settler hitting a Palestinian, so called
Just look at the whole picture
It's all cut off by CNN
It's all cut off by all the other media all over the world
and if you will see the whole picture you will see
that because those Arabs have been attacking Jews
sometimes Jews needed to defend themselves
and even if it seems to be a farmer
there have been many many incidents
where those so-called farmers
turned into
terrorists within one second
A relative of mine worked in Gush Katif (Gaza)
in the 1990s
He had a main worker
who worked for him for 17 years
after 17 years, he stabbed him to death
So I can't
trust any Arab
that he is innocent
unless he proves otherwise
That's taking a defensive posture
what about the other day the burning of olive groves?
Palestinian olive groves
Part of defending ourselves
is to make sure that Arabs don't want to deal with us
Simple as that
What does that mean? How is burning the olives groves...
It's turning the defensive into offensive that's all
I have no reason to be defensive if I didn't have to be defensive
So what's the difference between what they (Palestinians) do and what you do?
The difference is that
Aren't they (Palestinians) saying the same thing in their minds?
"I was defensive, now I have to be offensive"
"because it is the only way to get rid of these people"
There are two basic
there is a strategic look and a tactical look
Basically it goes back to the
to what we were talking about earlier
The historic background
Yes, I believe that this is my country
Even though that I believe this is my country
it doesn't mean that every Arab I see that I will kill him
just because it is my country
like we were talking earlier
I will give him three options
Even so
when he
tries to conquer my land
I will defend my land
and by planting those olive trees
he's conquering my land
That doesn't mean...
Isn't that land he owns?
First of all, no
How do you know this?
Because
I happen to know it very well
and here in this area (near Nablus, Tul Karem)
you have almost no
official
How do you say it?
Land deeds, tabu?
Tabu, yes - land deed
There are no official ones like that
the only thing there is here
We are near Tul Karem
are deeds from the Jordanian time (1948-1967)
the Jordanians came
which was in 1966
Not many years ago
and they said we want to take
Taxes
Taxes from you
Whose land is this?
Ok, this is Mohammad's land
They listed, this is Mohammad's land
This is his
amount of land he has
But that's the way it used to work at some point
Register
We are talking 50 years ago
That's all we are talking 60 years ago
But that is the system we live under
It is not an historic claim
It doesn't matter that is the system we live under
If I own a house in Ottawa or Tel Aviv
I buy it, I have a land deed
We don't live in biblical times
It wasn't bought
meaning that same Arab decided that he wants to claim for that land
the Jordanians will say
"of course, more taxes for us"
so he got the claim that second
It could be he got there that same day and said "this is my land"
meaning it is not an official claim
even so
it doesn't go way back
The most it will go is two generations ago
that's the most
you won't find Arabs...
The tabu or the person?
The person itself
Come on, there are people who... the Husseini (family) are here 1500 years at least
Tell me what percentage of the Arabs here have been here more than a couple hundred years?
I don't know I haven't done their genetic test
Not genetic test Just ask them where they are from
They will claim they are from here
Most of them will tell you that they were refugees that came from Syria
from Lebanon
They came to work
and you will see Look at the maps of land
since the Jews started coming back here
in the late 19th century
or the beginning of the 20th century
the Arabs came along to work here
Most of them weren't here before the 20th century
and Jews were always here
(Jews) were kicked out, exiled
the came back again and again
but this is their land, always
and so many of the Arab towns surrounding us
are called after Jewish towns
that are listed in the Bible
as Jewish towns
Give me an example
Right over here next to Ariel is
Kfil Haris
Kfil Haris in the Bible is called "Haris"
where (Biblical) Joshua was buried
and in Nablus
you have (Biblical) Joseph's tomb inside
That's the original place where Jacob, our forefather
came to...
and so many
and just here, on the other side of Yizhar
there is a place called Farhata
Farhata is listed in the Bible as Faraton
All these places are listed in the Jewish Bible
and the archeology shows that
You have Sebastia
not far away from here
which is the Jewish city
where the Israeli kingdom was
back in Biblical times, in the Temple times
which was Ahab, the king of Shomron, Omri
these are historic places
The Arabs don't go back that long
Since when was Mohammad (the Prophet)
How many years ago?
We are talking about 3500 years ago
They don't go back that long
So are we talking history? This is our land historically
You see the black over here Yes, you were saying
You can even see smoke behind it
Not really, it is all very hazy today
Friday, three weeks ago
Somebody comes over and says there is smoke from there
I run out and see
like they do every year
many times
they torched the fields back there
in order to try to burn my vineyard
So that's your land
My land
Behind, inside the black where you can see
are olive trees
that the Arabs harvest
In that fire, there were 200 olive trees burned By whom?
By Arabs
How do you know that Arabs started your fire and the other fire?
It started way way past where Jews ever go
next to the Arab grove
What will CNN show?
Who burned those olive trees?
Jews obviously
That's what they will claim
But you are saying it is Arabs that burn all of it
Why would they burn their own fields?
Because it is worth it for them
they don't really care about the land
It is worth it for them
to try to burn my vineyard
and burn their olives as well
You are saying it is the same fire
It is the same fire
I thought two different fires
No, they try to
burn my vineyard
and then they started their olives on fire
You can see that the fire
continued all the way under my house
200 volunteers here
fighting the fire
and if they weren't here
it wouldn't stop and my house would burn down
and then when I go down and try to put out the fire
I get stoned by the Arabs
so then I need to run after them
and then they take a film of that
and show me attacking them
You were asking why do we attack Palestinians
Look at the whole frame not at half of it
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét